top of page
Search

Rebuilding confidence before GCSEs: helping pupils who feel they’ve fallen behind

Steffi Hesketh
Oct 7
6 min read

“There’s no point. I’ll get it wrong anyway.”

When a pupil says this before they have even started, we need to understand what is behind it. They may have gaps in their knowledge, but they may also have stopped believing that trying will make a difference. As GCSEs get closer, that feeling can become harder to shift.


For me, confidence is one of the most important things we can help young people build across all their GCSE subjects. Pupils need knowledge and skills, but they also need to feel able to use them, ask questions and have another go when something goes wrong.


I have spent 15 years working in secondary schools and college, including with GCSE maths resit students, whose confidence can be at an all-time low. Some arrive feeling that their previous result has already told them what they are capable of. Before we can move forward, we need to help them see that improvement is still possible.


These are the approaches I have found most useful.

Build a relationship beyond your subject

Find out something about the young person sitting in front of you. What do they enjoy? Ice hockey? K-pop? Russian literature? It doesn’t have to be something you know much about. Asking a question and remembering the answer shows that you are interested in them.


For a pupil who has come to expect difficult conversations about attainment, being asked about something they love can make a real difference to how a lesson begins.


You don’t need to share every interest or turn every task into a themed activity. A brief conversation before the lesson or remembering to ask how their match went helps build a relationship over time.


Pupils notice whether we are patient, whether we take their questions seriously and whether we keep believing in them after a difficult lesson. That relationship can help them feel comfortable enough to admit they don’t understand, attempt an answer or accept feedback.


With resit students especially, I want them to feel that we are starting from where they are now. Their previous grade gives us information about their learning; it doesn’t tell us everything about them.


Find the difficulty beneath the feeling

“I’m rubbish at science” tells us how a pupil feels. It doesn’t tell us what to teach next.


They might struggle to recall key knowledge, apply it to an unfamiliar question or explain an answer clearly. They may understand more than their written work suggests but keep seeking reassurance because they don’t trust themselves.


A short classroom check can help: ask pupils to recall something, explain it and then use it. Brief written responses or mini-whiteboards allow us to hear from pupils who rarely volunteer as well as those who regularly contribute.


“Show me where you got stuck” is often more useful than asking whether they understand.

In English, a pupil may choose relevant evidence but struggle to explain it. In science, they may remember a process but miss a step when describing it. Identifying that difference gives us something specific to teach.


Research supports the connection between belief and attainment across academic learning. Talsma and colleagues’ review of 11 longitudinal studies found evidence of links in both directions: belief in being able to complete academic tasks was linked to later performance, and performance was linked to later belief. These findings were not specific to GCSEs, but they underline the value of helping pupils experience progress.


Praise the small steps and say what you noticed

Praise, praise, praise. Especially for pupils who struggle and may hear far more about what they need to improve than what they have done well.


The smallest steps can matter. A pupil starts without waiting for reassurance. They attempt five questions. They ask for help rather than giving up. They mark and correct their work without becoming frustrated.


Tell them you noticed.


“You started that independently today” gives them something concrete to recognise. “You spotted the mistake and corrected it yourself” helps them see that getting something wrong doesn’t have to end the task.


Praise needs to be sincere and appropriate to the pupil. Some enjoy public recognition; others would much rather hear it quietly as you pass their desk.


Our other words matter too. “I was always bad at maths” may be intended to reassure, but a pupil could hear it as confirmation that struggling with a subject is permanent. Describing work as impossible can discourage an attempt before it begins.


We can acknowledge difficulty while keeping improvement possible: “This is difficult at the moment. Let’s work out which part needs practice.”


Marsh and Martin’s research review found support for links between pupils’ views of their academic ability and their achievement. It also distinguished these beliefs from general self-esteem. Our encouragement therefore needs to connect with learning, so pupils can see what they are becoming more capable of doing.


Make the next goal manageable

“Revise English” is a large instruction for someone who already feels behind. A useful starting point might be five questions, one paragraph plan or beginning a short revision task independently.


Agree what the pupil will attempt, check it together and use what you find to decide the next step. Keep the goal achievable while giving them something worthwhile to learn.


When modelling work, explain your decisions: why you chose that evidence, how you organised an explanation or what you checked before moving on.


The Education Endowment Foundation recommends teaching pupils to plan, monitor and evaluate their learning within subject lessons. These habits give pupils practical ways to approach work with increasing independence.


Gradually reduce the support. A pupil might first use a model and prompts, then a checklist, and eventually tackle the task independently.


Keep an earlier attempt so they can compare it with their current work. Return to the skill later with a different question. Seeing that they can still do it, with less help, provides evidence they can draw on when the next challenge arrives.


Work with parents and carers

One of the best things I ever did was send positive emails home on a Friday to the parents and carers of struggling learners.


I would share something specific: their child had persevered with a difficult task, contributed an answer or made progress with something they had previously avoided.


It gave families something positive to talk about at home. It also showed pupils that I noticed their effort and improvement, rather than only contacting home when there was a problem.


Students wanted to try for me, and they did. Over time, they started to see the progress for themselves. They needed less reassurance and were more willing to have a go.


Communication with parents and carers also helps us understand what happens beyond the classroom. A pupil may be trying at home but unsure where to start, or becoming upset whenever revision is mentioned.


Clear priorities help. “Practise these questions and correct them afterwards” is easier to support than “They need to revise more.”


Keep their strengths and wider life in view

Success in a weaker subject can help a pupil feel more hopeful about their GCSEs overall. We shouldn’t assume confidence transfers automatically, but we can help them recognise useful habits they could apply elsewhere.


Sport is a good example. A pupil who trains regularly already has experience of practice, feedback and trying again after disappointment. Ask what helps them improve there and how that approach might help with schoolwork.


Keep talking about their strengths too. Their hardest subject shouldn’t become the subject of every conversation.


Family time, enjoyable activities and days off revision matter. Young people need space to enjoy their lives and spend time with people who value them beyond their results.


Confidence isn’t built overnight. There will still be difficult lessons and disappointing marks. Keep expectations clear, adjust the support and notice the next small step.


In your next lesson, look for one improvement a pupil might otherwise miss. Tell them what you noticed. Where appropriate, share it with home too.


Knowing someone believes in them, alongside repeated experiences of making progress, can help a pupil who once said “There’s no point” begin to think, “I’ll give it a go.”


Steffi Hesketh-Spells

Steffi Hesketh Tutoring



Sources

Talsma, K., Schüz, B., Schwarzer, R. and Norris, K. (2018). “I believe, therefore I achieve (and vice versa): A meta-analytic cross-lagged panel analysis of self-efficacy and academic performance.” Learning and Individual Differences, 61, pp. 136–150.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S104160801730211X


Marsh, H. W. and Martin, A. J. (2011). “Academic self-concept and academic achievement: Relations and causal ordering.” British Journal of Educational Psychology, 81, pp. 59–77.https://doi.org/10.1348/000709910X503501


Education Endowment Foundation (2025). Metacognition and Self-Regulated Learning: Guidance Report.https://educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/education-evidence/guidance-reports/metacognition



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page